Romantic comedy is my genre of choice, and I’m clearly not alone in this given the buzz surrounding the recent release of the Netflix produced romantic comedy Set It Up. Given the obvious appetite for these movies, it’s strange that Hollywood has neglected the genre in recent years. They’re relatively cheap to produce and appeal to a wide audience, and yet it feels like as a collective, us romcom fans have been surviving off corny Hallmark romances for so long. Romantic comedies offer a neat little package of 90-120 minutes of escapism and appeal to modern day fantasies of love and closure, which can be absent from our everyday lives.
Below you’ll find a list of a few of my favourites, the diamonds in the rough! Although I have to acknowledge the lack of diversity in the leads of the following movies is concerning. I could make a weak excuse and attribute that solely to the lack of diversity in Hollywood (SO excited for Crazy Rich Asians though, hopefully a sign of changing times). Although romantic comedies starring POC actors and actresses undoubtedly exist such as Bend It Like Beckham, Hitch, Already Tomorrow in Hong Kong, and Something New, they seem to be few and far between in Hollywood. However, despite considering myself a connoisseur in the genre of romantic comedy, I’m aware that I should still take this list as a sign that I should expand my palate, especially to non-Western films beyond Bride and Prejudice, because there are probably a lot of great films I’m missing.
The Heavyweight: Bridget Jones’ Diary. This is a staple of the genre. If I met an alien who desperately wanted to understand what romantic comedy was, I would sit them down and put this on, and then run screaming into the hills never to be seen again. A re-telling of Pride and Prejudice, Renee Zellweger is so charming and funny as is the whole supporting cast.
Most Unconventional: Lars and the Real Girl. I haven’t seen this in years and years, but I’ve never forgotten it and that must mean something… Though it could also mean that Ryan Gosling is so handsome that the impact of seeing his presence on film never leaves you. In this film Lars (played by Ry Gos) falls in love with a blow-up sex doll, Bianca, as if she is a real human woman. It sounds perverted but it’s very cute.
Classic: Barefoot in the Park. Robert Redford and Jane Fonda show that opposites do attract in this classic. They play two newlyweds trying to reconcile their differences as they get used to living together. Although the plot doesn’t go very far (or deep), the chemistry between the two leads is extremely compelling.
Miniseries, Pride and Prejudice (1995). I may have cheated with this one, because it’s not a movie at all but a miniseries. Furthermore, I don’t know if this is really a romantic comedy but humour underlies the entire thing, there are so many funny moments (especially those involving Mrs Bennett) and many commentators have recognised the source material as a comedy of manners. Maybe I’ll have to do a period romance post in future.
Television show: Lovesick. I’ve already cheated by including a miniseries so I’ll keep the tradition going by including a television show. It has often been argued of late that romantic comedy isn’t dead, it’s just moved to television.
Straight Man Doesn’t Luck Out for Once: Imagine Me & You. Follows the burgeoning relationship between Rachel and Luce, but unfortunately, Rachel is married to Hector. A sweet romance on its own, elevated by the fact that it is LGBT!
Another Austen-related pick: Austenland. I guess I love all things Jane Austen. Based on a novel by Shannon Hale (which I also loved), it follows a woman (Keri Russell) going on a holiday to a resort called Austenland where people role play as characters living in the time of Jane Austen’s works.
Jennifer Lopez’s Best: The Wedding Planner. Jennifer Lopez is truly a queen of the genre, but pending the release of her upcoming return in Second Act, I have to call The Wedding Planner as her best. This movie is hilarious and the chemistry between JLo and Matthew McConaughey sizzles.
Best Teen: Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging. So British, so good.
Most Neglected: Penelope. I feel like this movie is often overlooked, and I’m not sure why. Maybe it’s the slight fantasy-bent to the story? It stars Christina Ricci as a young woman who has been cursed with a literal pig snout and kept in isolation by her (loving) parents as a result. Please don’t let my terrible summary deter you, this movie is perfect for letting go of your stress. Also, who knew Sigur Rós would pair so well with a kissing scene?
Writing this list has just made me realise how many more films I could have included (and have yet to see). Regardless, I’m ready for new meat, viva la romcom revolution!